Sen. Joe Zarelli’s SB 5908 to throw out PERS 2 and PERS 3 and replace it with what’s basically a PERS 4 has not been scheduled for a vote in the Senate Ways and Means Committee.
At a hearing late Wednesday, the Zarelli bill got no support except from Zarelli.
It would create a new Public Employees Savings Plan (PSEP) for all new state employees hired effective Jan. 1, 2013. This would be a defined contribution plan, not a defined benefit plan like PERS 2 and half of PERS 3. Employees would contribute 5 percent up to age 35, 7.5 percent from 35 to 55 and 10 percent after that.
But as the Federation and other allies testified, Zarelli’s PERS 4 plan would provide less benefits and higher costs.
John Kwamme said Nebraska has a defined contribution plan for public employees, except for teachers who have a defined benefit plan. Over 30 years, the teachers with a defined benefit plan have come out further ahead.
And as Sen. Steve Conway of the 29th District pointed out, Social Security is a defined benefit plan and no one is advocating replacing it with a defined contribution plan.
The problem with unfunded liability doesn’t come from employees – in fact PERS 2 and 3 are fully funded. It comes because the Legislature failed to make its contributions to the system and instead gave away $3 billion tax breaks over the past 10 years.
At a hearing late Wednesday, the Zarelli bill got no support except from Zarelli.
It would create a new Public Employees Savings Plan (PSEP) for all new state employees hired effective Jan. 1, 2013. This would be a defined contribution plan, not a defined benefit plan like PERS 2 and half of PERS 3. Employees would contribute 5 percent up to age 35, 7.5 percent from 35 to 55 and 10 percent after that.
But as the Federation and other allies testified, Zarelli’s PERS 4 plan would provide less benefits and higher costs.
John Kwamme said Nebraska has a defined contribution plan for public employees, except for teachers who have a defined benefit plan. Over 30 years, the teachers with a defined benefit plan have come out further ahead.
And as Sen. Steve Conway of the 29th District pointed out, Social Security is a defined benefit plan and no one is advocating replacing it with a defined contribution plan.
The problem with unfunded liability doesn’t come from employees – in fact PERS 2 and 3 are fully funded. It comes because the Legislature failed to make its contributions to the system and instead gave away $3 billion tax breaks over the past 10 years.
CALL YOUR SENATOR: We assume nothing with Sen. Zarelli. So call 1-800-562-6000 and urge your senator to oppose SB 5908, the PERS 4 bill. It costs more and provides lower benefits to retirees.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comment Policy
We appreciate our readers and thank you for adding to the discussion. The following guidelines are established to ensure respectful tone in the comments of readers so we can all enjoy the site.
• Keep comments on topic - any comment that appears to be off-topic will be edited or deleted.
• Profanity - we’re PG13 here. Moderate language is allowed, but we reserve the right to edit out anything offensive.
• Personal attacks - personal attacks on the authors or other commentators will result in an immediate ban.
• Editor’s right - While we encourage comments that challenge or offer constructed criticism, we reserve the right to edit or remove any post, and to ban a user.*
• External linking - external links are ok, if they are relevant to the original post and your comment. Simply linking to your own site will be frowned upon.
Final Words
You, and only you, are responsible for your words. Once your comment is submitted, that’s it — you’re immortalized. Think before you submit.
*WFSE members are protected under the following Communications Ethics policy:
Under the provisions of the AFSCME “Bill of Rights for Union Members” regarding communications, “Members shall suffer no impairment of freedom of speech concerning the operations of this union. Active discussion of union affairs shall be encouraged and protected within this organization.”
If you believe your comments were removed unfairly, you may protest the removal of your post to the Communications Committee. Leave your protest at Contact Us on WFSE.org